Catch Steak New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Catch Steak New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Catch Steak New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Catch Steak New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Catch Steak New York
Booked 8 times by Catch Steak New York customers.
Ranked #8 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 7 times by Catch Steak New York customers.
Ranked #2 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 2 times by Catch Steak New York customers.
Ranked #4 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Catch Steak New York customers.
Ranked #57 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Booked 1 times by Catch Steak New York customers.
Ranked #1 in New York's Best Restaurants.
Catch Steak New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
20 Reviews
0 Replys |
Best Steak in NYC
Had dinner with friends at Catch to celebrate a birthday! Best steak in NYC! Great ambiance and wonderful service!
Be the first to ReplyNot coming back
We were recommended to go in Catch Steak, so we were willing to try the place out. The place is really pretty, the decoration is on point, but the main reason for our discontent was the poor service, the prices and the ambiance. Our waitress was cold, agressive and not sympathetic. The waiting times were terrible, we waited nearly 40mins for two meals and two sides. She really insisted on us ordering starters, and it felt totally unprofessional to do so. The place was also very loud, we couldnโt hear each other and the music was not it. Overhaul the food was great, it really is a shame that such nice food came with such a bad place. The meat was delicious and they even had some vegetarian options. Still, the prices were way too expensive for the small quantities they served. We sincerely hope that this place can become better.
Be the first to ReplyJust drink in your room
Staying at the connecting hotel. Tried to get drinks-at the bar. The bartender wouldnโt even make eye contact-45 minutes before closing. After 10 minutes of sitting with absolutely no contact even though we were 1 foot away, we decided they didnโt want to sell a $20 drink per person. Great service. Not
Be the first to ReplyWorst experience everrrrrrr
Worst experience ever. It took almost 2 hours for us to even get an appetizer. The waiters and manager showed no remorse. Very terrible service they treated us like peasants.
Be the first to ReplySave your money and go to a real steakhouse
Very disappointing experience. The worst wagyu steak Iโve ever had. Service is mediocre, at best. They plop a $100 steak in front of you like youโre eating at McDonalds. Save your money.
Be the first to ReplyNot Worth The Trouble โฆ
On Saturday 14th June I made reservations to go to Catch Steak New York and I was appalled by the service. We had a booking for 9.15pm and when we arrived we were told the table wasnโt ready. We have never been before so were not told about a bar or offered to buy a drink we just stood by reception with several other customers who were told the same thing. After some time we were told to move into a bar area and informed that we would be called once the table was ready. Myself and my partner noticed 3 other couples who arrived after us were seated before and so asked again about our reservations. After waiting just under an hour we were seated and as it was now so late we just ordered mains. This did not arrive until 11pm nearly 2 hours after our reservation! No apologies were made which is such a shame as the food, atmosphere and our personal waitress were actually impressive but the service was ruined by our experience at the Front of House which ultimately effected the whole evening. I will not be going again and wouldnโt recommend as the food was not worth the terrible level of service.
Be the first to ReplyPLEASE AVOID TERRIBLE
We saved up for a long time to come to nyc from the Uk. We googled lots of restaurants and got recommendations from friends regards steak houses so we decided to choose here. We arrived on time and got thrown into the very busy bar for 30 mins to โwaitโ for our table even though we pre booked. We then got seated and had very little to no service the whole time. They took our order then 1 hour still no food it was now 10:30pm at night and our stomachs were in pain! We got up and left and suddenly the staff started being attentive and chasing us to come back in. We thought they may offer a free meal but NO they were more concerned if weโd had drinks we hadnโt paid for in which we replied of course not we hadnโt of walked out without paying for drinks we are not criminals! We had tap water!! It actually ruined our whole holiday, so please please donโt do the same and go to a smaller restaurant where they appreciate your custom and care about you
Be the first to ReplyOne of the worst experiences so far
I was waiting 30 minutes when I paid 200$ dollars to get my reservation for 8 people and after 30 minutes we were still in the bar waiting for no reason while everybody was getting inside
Be the first to ReplyGreat experience
From service to steaks - itโs been an excellent experience and we would definitely revisit again. Watch out though for the seating outside - we had to request being seated inside in early November. Itโs rather cold and less cozy outside but staff complied quickly and changed our request to be taken inside venue. Order the brussel sprouts if they are in season.
Be the first to ReplyDisappointing
Unfortunately we will likely not be back! Although the sommelier was one of the best we have ever experienced, unfortunately we paid $450 for a sub par dinner way below expectations. We ordered the rib cap and were promised Au Jus from the prime rib special that we would have ordered k owing that the dinner would be served without the Au Jus that was promised. Very disappointing as no apology was delivered by the waitress and we even asked for a little Au Jus to be given with the left overs which was not obliged. We would have expected much more for such of an establishment.
Be the first to ReplyBUYER BEWARE
Advanced booking, informed table would be kept for 15 mins. Arrived on time and herded into a bar area full of guests awaiting their table allocation. Waited in this area 35min despite twice being told our table would be ready shortly. Table we were allocated was an average 4 seater with basic uncomfortable chairs. The food was all very good, fillet and delmonico steaks. But we had to wait almost an hour between starter and main courses! Waitress service was below average. At the end of our meal we discussed at length if a gratuity tip was deserved, we decided it was not. However, when I checked my credit card account I discovered the waitress had dipped my card for $40! I followed this up with the Catch Steak office and managed to get this sum put back onto my account. There are much better steakhouse restaurants in NYC than this one. Buyer beware...
Be the first to ReplyTerrible! The reservation was for 2:15 PM, yet no one was seated at that time! The bar's service was awful! I would neve
Terrible! The reservation was for 2:15 PM, yet no one was seated at that time! The bar's service was awful! I would never advise. attempting to convey the vibe of a chic, upmarket hangout, but is a little over their heads. Would not advise. DO NOT COME HERE. I've never written a review before, but the low quality of the service drove me to do so.
Be the first to ReplyAn unforgettable experience
We are here in New York from Aruba our Server was William he gave us the best service and the food and drinks where amazing the baked alaska was toped for after an amazing dinner, we would definitely be back on our next trip.
Be the first to ReplyYou will never CATCH Me Here Ever Again, It's BAD
Catch Steak beginning with the name itself. It's a bait and switch. It's not a Steak House. It only offers two steaks. Options a poor quality filet mignon which they cut in half and cubes like you were a child a horrible presentation. We ordered oysters which we returned as they were unstable, we ordered a tuna sushi roll which was ok, but it cost $38.00, we tried to order wine, but the waiter never returned. We went to seek him to get the check. Paid left NEVER TO Return.
Be the first to ReplyCool Vibe
Saturday night hot spot for the young and old alike. The food was good but the biggest attraction is the cool people there.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food Great vibe
Stumbled in after attending an event nearby. Bar staff was welcoming and friendly as we awaited the opening of the main dining area.
Within an hour the entire place was packed with a very diverse crowd (age, attireโฆ.) music was appropriate and diverse as well. The vibe was lively and the energy was high.
Our meal arrived and the experience continued in the right direction. The charred broccoli was an item that I would recommend. There wasnโt a surf and turf option but they did allow us to add a lobster skewer to our steak and it was peppery and delicious!
Bad experience
Almost 2 hours to get our food! and once it arrive it was inedible! The 8oz steak was 5oz and mega over cooked, the corn side was from Cambells but kind of rotten, the salmon was raw and the crust was giughhh. It took me 30 minutes to get a zip of a Vodka Tonic which actually they brought it soda, not tonic. We left! The manger (Emily) did apologize and offer us to change everything or at least a dessert but we were not in the mood anymore. I just pay for the 5 slice sushi roll they brought us as an appetizer which was eeeeโฆ We left and had a slice of pizza in the corner instead.
Be the first to Replydinner in the big apple!
a great restaurant. food is amazing its not cheap but worth the splurge! they insist on pre-mixing drinks before bringing them to the table which i did not like. its a very busy venue and the tables are tightly packed in. service was good and friendly.
Be the first to ReplyReally nice night even though it was cold out
First time at the Catch Steakhouse
Went with Jason John and Doug.
We had a very nice night
we started with a seafood combination of shrimp, crab and oysters
We all had steak and I had the porterhouse which was outstanding
and cooked perfectly
We had the frenchfries cook in duck fat.
Were really tasty
we spilt the snickers baked alaskan
excellent all around.
Low class
My fiancรฉ and I made a reservation for his 35th birthday. We are professional people with high standards. We were appalled by the lack of respect and professionalism of this staff. Especially while we specified that we were celebrating a special occasion. We were seated and changed to a booth due to the very small tables and chairs (other booths occupied 2 people as well). The hostess then came over after we had ordered and had drinks and asked us to move back to the smaller table. MIND you the restaurant is EMPTY on a Wednesday night and we are in a pandemic- not exaggerating as restaurants are NEVER filled as it is currently against the law. We were standing in the middle of restaurant and completely embarrassed as the hostess came back to say she could not accommodate a request for bigger seating (in this empty restaurant). The manager was then involved and also did nothing to accommodate or appease the situation. This restaurant seems to only accommodate a specific stereo type. A rude and low class establishment. Checked on opened table 30 minutes later and they had reservations for up to even 6 people. Not sure the reason for the lie. Glad I decided to leave. Restaurant canceled my reservation so I couldnโt leave a bad review on open table. If your looking for wagyu beef steak in specific- we ended up in TAO next door- been there a bunch of times but first time trying their wagyu and it was terrific.
Be the first to Reply