AppointmentTrader FAQ - Holly Jolly Holiday Bar New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Holly Jolly Holiday Bar New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Holly Jolly Holiday Bar New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Holly Jolly Holiday Bar New York Reviews from The Last Year
When we arrived at Holly Jolly, we were told that they were
When we arrived at Holly Jolly, we were told that they were fully booked out despite the abundance of seating and, as we soon learned, available online reservations. We should have heeded the host and went elsewhere, but instead we dutifully paid the absurd price per person and entered what could only be described as the epitome of the lowest effort NYC tourist trap. As we walked in, a group of clearly drunk women screamed "this place is amazing, you'll love it!" at us; sign no. 1 that we should have promptly turned around and left. The general decor was cheap but instagrammable if you got the right angle -- but the menu didn't even try. Not a single holiday themed cocktail existed. Putting "merry" in front of Moscow Mule does not make it anything other than a Moscow Mule. Now, it could have been salvaged with at least half an effort somewhere. Either cute glassware / presentation, or at least a serviceable drink. Neither existed. The drinks were terrible -- my espresso martini was at once way too sweet and way too boozy, with the saddest little plastic ornament bobbing around as holiday decor. My husband's coffee drink came with curdled cream and not even the smallest attempt at a festive presentation; and our friends' drinks basically tasted like it was poured out of a vat of pre-mixed cocktails made by someone who only has the vaguest sense of what a cocktail is. Getting mugged outside the bar would have likely felt like a less insulting use of our
Mad Morton is the place where they have the Holly Jolly
Mad Morton is the place where they have the Holly Jolly Holiday bar. We had a 3:30pm reservation for a table for 4 but we ended up only being 2 people. We got here early and tried to see if we could be seated earlier. At first they said no but then they came back to us and said they could seat us at a table. this place looked better on instagram but we still had fun and enjoyed our holiday drinks. I had the snowman martini and then a hot chocolate with vodka and it comes in a cute christmas tree mug. And my friend had a drink with prosecco and strawberry and lemon something. Her drink came with an ornament where you had to pour the strawberry liquid into the drink. And then she also had the hot chocolate. Both of our drinks were tasty. Our waitress was very nice and attentive. She was super! very friendly too. If you want to be in the holiday spirit you should come check this place out but you really should make reservations in advance since it is a very popular place.
If you're looking for a fun and not super chaotic Christmas
If you're looking for a fun and not super chaotic Christmas bar I highly recommend this. The staff was super friendly and we were seated very quickly and the drinks were all fantastic. For the $15 ticket off bucket listers I think it's well worth it and it was a great spot to be able to talk with friends and not have to talk over the music or other people.
If you're looking for a Christmas bar, look no further--
If you're looking for a Christmas bar, look no further-- this is a super cute one with tons of Christmas cheer! We had an awesome server named Christy P. She was so accommodating and gave good recs! I loved all the presentation of all the drinks! My favorite was the hot chocolate with baileys. The ornamentini was pretty good but pretty strong on lemon. My friend got the polar espresso which she enjoyed! This bar will certainly put you in the holiday spirit!! Check it out, but make sure you have a reservation!
I came for the Jolly Holly Holiday Bar pop up bar that's
I came for the Jolly Holly Holiday Bar pop up bar that's happening for Christmas. The place decor is great and its very cozy. With the price of $22 PP ticket you get a holiday theme cocktail. I tried a few cocktails and they were all very festive, tasty and very strong which I really enjoyed. The food is average. We got the fried calamari, fried chicken chunks, guacamole and cheesecake. I highly recommend this place for great pics and drinks. If you want to see videos of my visit https://youtu.be/GWSGWhfdU5k?si=ja-JgTgEquCH3tOd
This place is cute and festive but my experience was
This place is cute and festive but my experience was nothing short of bizarre so I would not recommend it to anyone. Let's just say you shouldn't make your customers feel unwelcome, especially when your place is half-empty. First off, the hostess needs to learn how to speak to customers. My ticket said I had the table for 90 minutes from 5:00 until 6:30. I arrived around 5:30 because I was stuck in traffic but thought an hour was long enough to eat a burger and grab a drink. She told me that she was "fully booked" so we better hurry up because she couldn't guarantee that I could keep my table past 6:30. Turns out that no one came AT ALL, which you can see from my photo so I'm not sure why you'd want to rush a paying customer out before they even sat down when you know you're not fully booked. LOL Just not a good business move for a place that was not exactly packed for the entirety of my meal. I guess we weren't the right demographic that they typically get but my money is still green so I didn't appreciate the rudeness. The waiter also had no idea what he was doing. We told him we'd have 3 burgers but asked for one of them with no cheese. He confirmed what temp we wanted them cooked but then only served 1 burger. We waited about 10 minutes for the other burgers to arrive but nothing came. When we asked him where they were, he said we only ordered 1. I don't even have words for the poor service. No napkins, no utensils, nor even ketchup for our burgers. As if this isn't weird enough, we saw him in the corner eating coleslaw with his bare hands out of a big tub like he never saw food before. I'm not even sure what to say other than don't waste your time here. The staff seriously needs to be re-trained.
Bought tickets for the holly jolly holiday bar from
Bought tickets for the holly jolly holiday bar from bucketlisters and did not meet expectation. Ordered the Polar Express Martini and expected it to come out like the picture from the buckerlisters posting but it was different. Would recommend changing the menu to add if a drink is served hot or cold because we ordered a drink and didn't realized it came out hot. The holiday decorations looked kind of cheap. For the price you pay for the ticket/drink and experience, I feel there are better holiday bar options to choose from instead of this.
Came to Mad Morton for the Holly Jolly pop up through
Came to Mad Morton for the Holly Jolly pop up through BucketListers and it honestly was such a let down. I was really disappointed, considering the fact that tickets were $25 each. The welcome drink that was included seemed like a nice offering, up until I received mine. I ordered the one that seemed equivalent to an espresso martini and it was so bad. It tasted like rubbing alcohol. It was so bad I had to tell our waiter we didn't like it and I usually never do that. He was actually very sweet and immediately brought me a new one. Unfortunately, even that one was not good either so at that point I just gave up. The area we were seated in was also not the best. It didn't feel like we were at a Christmas themed bar. Specifically our area just felt like a regular bar with some Christmas decorations. I don't recommend the experience. For anyone interested in going, save your $$ because it's not worth it at all.
I attended their Frankenstein-themed event for Halloween
I attended their Frankenstein-themed event for Halloween and had an absolute blast so I had to come back for their Holly Jolly-themed event. The food is always good, especially their calamari and Mad Morton burger. Their chicken tacos & truffle fries are delicious as well. Hands down the best holiday cocktails I've seen or tasted. The service is always great and the bartenders are the best. I love their ticketed time slots because they really honor them. It's not crowded and everybody has a seat because of their 90-minute reservations. Ticket includes 1 themed cocktail. It's always a vibe!!!! Will attend every event they have!! Ig:Thefunfluencer
Found out about the Holly Jolly Holiday themed bar off
Found out about the Holly Jolly Holiday themed bar off bucket listers. I reserved a table for two and the tickets came with a cocktail for each of us. I had two drinks and was feeling real nice! We ordered the meatballs, burger, steak sandwich and Brussel sprouts. Everything delicious! I'd come back here not during holiday season also for those Brussel sprouts.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Holly Jolly Holiday Bar New York
AppointmentTrader FAQ
Questions and Answers around the platform.
56,624 People following
964 Questions
661 Answers |
Ask a question about AT |
Tune into NBC News - Top Story Tonight 7:40p ET |
Let’s go. Get more people placing bids!
I will give you 50% of ALL of my PROFITS if you teach me how to make profits? |
LOL. Thank you The New Yorker.
Appointment |
Transferring reservations is not supported in AT. Why not just use the name in the AT screenshot?
Buyers interested in Bern's Steakhouse: PLEASE READ |
Same goes for 4 Charles and I Sodi
Prepaid Reservation Fee |
Agreed. Ultimately not addressing this month after month is clearly resulting in a drop in certain venue’s rankings & sales.
Congrats on 3 mil |
🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🍾🧨🧨🧨 now on to 30 mill!
Need to cancel a bid, not getting a response… how do I do it? |
Click on "Take off the Market Option" in your portfolio
Working on your bid? |
Your bid has been “matched” with a reservation. From the time a reservation has been located, the seller of the reservation must connect with moderator to give transfer information for reservation. If the seller;however, does NOT respond to reservation transfer, then your bid is reprocessed and returns to the first step, which is connecting your request to a reservation.
Process after bid is accepted. |
Hey @EvocativeFold67, welcome to appointmenttrader! Once the reservation is in your portfolio, you definitely own the timeslot, the review team would not have approved the trade if the reservation wasn't confirmed - so you are going :-) Judging from your post you bid today and are going tomorrow - don't worry as long as you initiated the name transfer, you are good - the transfer service has to work with the opening hours of the reservation team of the respective venue. You will likely see the transfer confirmation a couple hours before your reservation time.
Where do the Reservations on AppointmentTrader come from? |
Mostly from people who don't need their reservations or appointments any longer. AT has no relationship with places listed and acts as a platform connecting buyers and sellers making sure that listed reservations are real and that privacy is not compromised when transacting.
What happens if my bid expires unanswered? |
Hey @FluffyStar64, thanks for the question! When you place your bid the amount gets transferred in a deposit account, the second you either cancel your bid or a few minutes after the bid expires the funds are moved back into your main account from where you can refund it to your payment method or use for other transactions.
Any seller support?
Has anyone found a way to get a question answered? From what I can tell there is no way to get in touch with anyone that works at/for AT. Other than the occasional admin posting a consultation offer here and there they are non existent. A lot of people have the same issue I have where we cannot cash out earnings. I cannot get my warning medal removed even though I am under the threshold. Sad to say but seems like AT is holding up everyone’s funds currently. Very scary and makes me wonder….Please reply if you read this admins and can help. Tried every way possible to get in touch
Give the best answerWhat happens if someone changes or shows up for their reservation after I buy it?
As the title says. I bought a reservation but what’s to stop someone from just showing up for it anyway? I’m doing the name change service but it’s still under their email/phone, right?
Give the best answerBOT suggestions
Seems like its impossible now to grab anything with restaurents booked within seconds. Any good bot suggestions?
How long to get verified for payouts?
How long does it take to get verified for payouts? Submitted my info on Monday and still nothing
Give the best answerRestaurant Bought/Canceled Their Own Reservation
I accepted a bid for a popular restaurant in Los Angeles only to receive a phone call shortly thereafter informing me that the reservation had been canceled due to it being listed on AT. I of course need to subsequently cancel the reservation on AT but get this warning that my status will be negatively affected for doing so. I've reached out to customer support about this several times with no response, not sure what to do in this station. Hoping someone can advise.
Give the best answerWaiting on a transfer for tonight’s reservation
I’m waiting on a transfer request to be completed. But the reservation is for tonight. Can I still use the reservation if it’s not in my name.
Give the best answerPayout
I need to be paid for the two reservations I sold as a new user before I do more work to get and sell reservations only to not be paid. Can someone get back to me so I can get my funds. I don't understand the error message about the percentage. PLEASE HELP!
Give the best answerQuestion about postpaid listings for prepaid bookings
I have a prepaid reservation, but I'm allowed to transfer that reservation to others for a price that I set (up to the total price I paid).
For selling POSTPAID reservations, do I charge the buyer the full amount of the reservation when transferring? And then the buyer pays something on top of that (which is what is listed in the AppointmentTrader listing?)
Major Issue for Seller
My money is being held hostage! Can you please remove my refund medal as I am below the 11% threshold and should be able to withdraw my full daily amount now? I have been teying for a long time to get a reply on this. Major issue for people looking to do good/right like you ask and make positive sales. Being able to access earned revenue is critical and not getting any reply is very concerning for your sellers. Lot of other people having the same issue. Once below the threshold you should auto remove the warning medals.
Give the best answerHow does appointment trader work
Where can I learn more about how this works
Give the best answerWell through rate holding money for 180 days
Just wanted to put this out there as I find it quite weird. AT will hold money if your sell through rate is to low. I find this strange as you would think that sell through rate should reflect more on AT not marketing their site well enough to generate sales. It seems weird to punish sellers for listings not selling.
Give the best answerNo cares
Why is no one even looking at my reservations let alone send me a bud? They are top rest on weekends…any tips??
Give the best answerHow do I promote my first listing?
Any ideas on how to promote my first listing (reservation for tonight)?
Give the best answerHow can I access a buyer's bid listing?
I am trying to see if they would accept a smaller table size, how can I interact with the buyer?
Give the best answer4 Charles black listed me?
I had a bunch of resys and they cancelled them all and now when I get an alert and try to book it says the reservation is no longer available... has this happened to anyone else? Any recommendations on what to do?
Give the best answerPayouts
Anyone can help with payouts, support hasn’t been helpful at all. My funds cleared and I can only retrieve $50 usd a day with a $5 fee and a % per transaction. It would take so long and so much in fees. Thanks!
Give the best answerDoes support work ?
I am having a tough time contacting and elucidating a response from AT Support. I had a listing at 6pm, which was a mistake as the actual listing reservation was at 11pm. This got somehow approved by AT, and a customer bought this from me for 6pm. I want to cancel this listing and refund customer , but there is no way of doing this ! This is so frustrating and making me lose hope on AT. Can someone help me please?
Give the best answerDoes customer service exist!!!!?????
This app is horrible I bought a res it was listed as one day but the actual res on a different day. Have messaged support non stop no reply. There goes $200+ thanks appt trader! Such a scam
Give the best answerPayment for selling
How do I receive information if someone wants to buy my reservation? How do I get paid?
Give the best answerHow can we take our restaurant off your list?
Dear Appointmenttrader Team,
I am the spokesman of the Hofbräuhaus in Munich/Germany.
We don not want to be on your App, since Reservations in the Hofbräuhaus are free.
Please take us off this list!
Please do answer and confirm this.
Thank you and best regrads
Tobias
Medien Hofbräuhaus
Banned from Resy for selling reservations- Do we have a rat on our hands???
I am new to this app and started off by selling a polo bar reservation and then quickly sold one more reservation. Not long after I received emails from Resy saying all my reservations are cancelled and I am being banned from Resy for life. How could this have possibly happened without a rat telling Resy that I sold the reservation. I need some advice on this situation and let’s catch the rat!
Give the best answerBid and Buy Instantly
I have a big ongoing and it also shows someone is working on my bid. Today I see there is a " Buy Instantly " option at my portfolio showing same price I've bid for a reservation. I'm a bit confused, since my money has already been deducted from my credit card for the bid, do I need to pay one more time for the Buy Instantly? If I choose Buy Instantly, can I cancel my bid ( while someone is working on it )? Thanks!
Give the best answerFirst Sale Help
Having hard time getting my first sale. Any advice? I just want to get the ball rolling! Thanks!
Give the best answerChanging restaurant opening times
I have a reservation for Kasama Chicago I listed but it’s not showing up because the listed opening hours are only until 3 or 4 pm. My reservation is for their dinner service at 5. Is there a way I can change the times myself?
Give the best answerI got charged twice for a single reservation
How long until I get a refund? Support has been slow, has anyone else experienced this?
I tried purchasing the reservation at $55 but it failed. Then I purchased it for $30 and it succeeded. However the $55 charge still went through on my card and posted