Hunt & Fish Club New York Yelp Reviews - Hunt & Fish Club New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Hunt & Fish Club New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Hunt & Fish Club New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Hunt & Fish Club New York
Hunt & Fish Club New York Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
37 Reviews
0 Replys |
Regret choosing this place.
Hostesses were rude, server was absent, they cleared us out in a hurry (we were not in a rush), steak was cold and super salty. We did have a friend, * cough, a cockroach, visit and hide under the table mid dinner so that was exciting. Overall, food was super average but the service just wreaked of "we know you, as a tourist, won't ever come back and we will get new ole like you here forever." Pick somewhere else. The pictures make this place look way cooler than it is.
Be the first to ReplyI ordered the $74 kosher ribeye and it was mediocre at best.
Bland and slightly chewy. I would expect way more for this price. I am stunned that this place somehow got the reviews it did
Be the first to ReplyPretty standard for upscale midtown - not a particularly
Pretty standard for upscale midtown - not a particularly adventurous menu but it offers something for everyone. Our group started with a seafood tower of oysters, lobster, crap and shrimp - everything was fresh although being from the west coast I find east coast oysters rather bland and these were no exception. For my entree I chose the broccoli rabe ravioli which could have used a little more sauce and a little less cooking time as the ravioli became gluey, although that may also have been because it sat too long before making it to the table - it was lukewarm at best. The rest of the group had steak, salmon and scallops which they enjoyed. Som service was informative without being pretentious. Our service was excellent, from the hostess to the bartender to the som to our table server. The dining room is absolutely stunning with an art deco design and gorgeous lighting.
Be the first to ReplyI visited this restaurant at the end of January to
I visited this restaurant at the end of January to celebrate my birthday with a few friends. Service: They provided an amazing service from the bar to the table. The female bartender was very polite, very quick and attentive. The staff were also very pleasant when we walked in. They took our coats and placed them in coat check for us. Once seated for dinner we had server that seemed like a supervisor. He was extremely friendly, very polite and professional. He catered to our every need. Food: The food was really good... I had the New York strip...unfortunately I asked for well done and it came out medium rare. Once I sent it back it came out quickly. The mash potatoes were amazing! I was surprised with a chocolate cake which was very well decorated and delicious. Ambiance: Very beautifully decorated. Sexy and romantic... great place to celebrate a birthday dinner or have a date night. I enjoyed this restaurant... I hope to be back soon!
Be the first to ReplyH&F was an overall decent experience.
It's smack down in the middle of zero parking so be prepared to pay for parking. I paid $35 for 4-5hrs. They offer complimentary coat check which is cool. Food: ehhh, it was alright. The bread, creamy spinach and mash potatoes were delicious. My ribeye tasted regular. Nothing memorable nor finger licking good. Most of the meals range between $25-100. Drinks: Drinks were great. A little expensive but what do you expect dining in Manhattan. I would recommend this place if you're open to exploring new experiences.
Be the first to ReplyGreat meal all around.
Started bread is phenomenal, also had the lump crab, crab cake, mushroom pasta and bone in ribeye. All very excellent. Creamed spinach was just ok, I've had much better. Dessert were amazing, the baked Alaska is to dieeee for!!!
Be the first to ReplyHad a wonderful time.
This has been a hot spot for years and I finally got a chance to try it. We were seated promptly for a late dinner at 10:30 pm and the waiter came over to take our food orders before our drinks in order to ensure the kitchen received it in time. They gave us one popover per guest with this incredible herby whipped butter that was served room temp. Everything done right and probably the best popover I've ever had (with the butter). We then started off with the crab cake and the bone marrow which were both excellent. The crab cake didn't come with lemon because it didn't need it! Perfectly bright and seasoned from the acidity of the salad on top. The bone marrow was also great, plenty of marrow but I preferred it without the apricot type spread that accompanied it. We then got the 10 oz filet to share med rare and they asked if we wanted it sliced so we opted in. The steak was perfectly salted. Always an issue I have at other restaurants but there wasn't even any salt on the table because they know we wouldn't need it! So refreshing. We also got a dish of pasta per person, I got the gnocchi with caviar and lobster and wow so great!! I wish the sauce was a little thicker but no problem. We didn't get dessert but nevertheless the food was incredible and you cannot forget to mention easily recognizable gorgeous decor. I'd be back!!!
Be the first to ReplyFor and service was great as well as the drinks.
I would recommend the boneless rib eye medium if you like it medium well.
Be the first to ReplyI was really excited to come here for my birthday but I'm
I was really excited to come here for my birthday but I'm not sure if I will return. The food was amazing BUT the service was not the best. From the host to the waiter they were very standoffish and rude. Because of that I took away two stars.
Be the first to ReplySo this place was a bit disappointing for me.
We sat down and the waiter immediately had an attitude with us. I'm not sure why or what the issue was but even when trying to lighten up the mood, he just wasn't having it. Not friendly at all. After complaining amongst ourselves about the rudeness, we were served by another waitress who was actually really great. This was around the time we received our entrees. She was great and I really wish I remembered her name because she saved my friends birthday dinner. We came here for my friend's birthday dinner and mainly came for the steak. I ordered the filet mignon and asked for it to be cooked medium from the first waiter. As you can see from the picture posted, it was pretty close to well done for me, which I frankly don't enjoy especially from that cut of steak. Not sure if it was an assumption made about me or if the restaurant genuinely thought that this level was medium, but it felt like a waste for a 50$ cut of meat with know sides. Very disappointing. The bartenders were the gem of the restaurant and made us perfectly balanced cocktails. They and the last waitress are the reason why I'm giving this place a 2 and not a 1. But the food wasn't incredible. The mashed potato's were pretty god, but felt like I was eating a tub a butter more than anything. Expected a little more from this restaurant especially at that price point.
Be the first to ReplyBeautiful place, the decor is truly beautiful.
But the food? Overpriced and VERY underwhelming.We went right before the New YEAR and perhaps that contributed to the experience but....please, do not serve grapefruit juice which is clearly fermented.Also burata should be liquid inside and should ooze and spread lovingly while cut in half. If it doesn't, if it has crumbles inside it means only one thing, it was frozen and defrosted. WHO does that? Well, I did once and that's how I know. After that orange juice and the burrata (in fact two of them, for my adult child and myself), you kind of lost me.The presentation of the food did not match the decor, the side dishes were just veggies piled on top of plate, no garnish, no beautiful. For $20 I expect my mushrooms to be nicely presented. And my burrata fresh.I am not sure who this place caters to but the servers were either very unengaged, or so reverent as to make me uncomfortable. It gave the whole experience a little weird vibe. If you like this kind of treatment and have big bucks o spare, do go there! As I said, the decor is great!<a href="/redir?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.tripadvisor.com%2FShowUserReviews-g60763-d7375622-r882215191-Hunt_Fish_Club-New_York_City_New_York.html&s=fb5fa556482a4b4b83081bed20c0c15581f2e86c25f3e3755078a7470840beca" target="_blank" rel="nofollow">tripadvisor.com/ShowUserโฆ</a>
Be the first to ReplyI have a group of friends and 4 out of 6 of us have
I have a group of friends and 4 out of 6 of us have birthdays at the end of Feb or beginning of March so we came here on a Saturday night for our annual birthday dinner extravaganza and it was magnificent.We started out at the bar with some amazing cocktails. The bar is beautiful and the bartenders are artists. Really exceptional. We moved into the gorgeous dining room and sat at a round table. The room was lively and there was good background music but had excellent acoustics and you could actually hear everyone at the table without shouting! It's an amazing concept that other restaurants should consider...allowing guests to be able to converse with one another in a relaxed environment. It's a key differentiator, for sure and I loved being able to connect with everyone in the group.We had several appetizers, all delicious but especially the seafood salad, the carpaccio and the mixed green salad. The popovers served when we sat down were also outstanding, esp with the herb butter that was served to accompany them. Most everyone got steak for entrees but I was already so full, I went with the mushroom pasta which was phenomenal. So rich and delicious. For sides, we had asparagus, mashed potatoes and Brussels sprouts. The sprouts were good but the potatoes were out of this world. They were on the thinner side, which I usually don't like but these transported me. I don't want to know how much butter, cream and/or salt was in them....all I want to know is how soon I'm going back to have them again.If you have a special occasion to celebrate, this should be on your list as a place to consider. This will now go into my rotation for restaurants I go to when I want to impress my guests.
Be the first to ReplyCame here for my cousin bday.
The food and drinks were amazing!! The waitress was really nice and helpful with helping me to choice a good drinks. I recommend this place!!
Be the first to ReplyEverything about this place is amazing and handles the
Everything about this place is amazing and handles the three factors that you look for in any restaurant. FSA (Food, Service, Atmosphere). This place has it all. The food is always spectacular. I got the Hazed & Confused cocktail which was so good. Their Tiramisu is so good you wish you never tried it because it next level good. This place is great for a date, anniversary, business functions, and special occasions. I recommend this place to any foodie looking for their next culinary experience Shoutout to Matthew behind the bar. Great bartender.
Be the first to ReplyGreat experience! Waitress was perfectly attentive and
Great experience! Waitress was perfectly attentive and helpful, food was outstanding, and the ambiance is exactly what you want in a Times Square Steakhouse. The only knock was that the ancillary staff (helpers, busser, etc) were a bit overbearing and the cost check took 20 minutes to find our coats.
Be the first to ReplyThe complimentary coat check, clean bathrooms, high
The complimentary coat check, clean bathrooms, high ceilings, and bar space designed completely different from the main dining sets the restaurant apart from most long before the food comes out. When the drinks come, it confirms that you are indeed not in any regular restaurant. I did not order a cocktail but after tasting my partners drink, it became a shared drink. We both ordered pasta(informed that these were smaller dishes by the amazing wait staff), and sides that included Oysters, brocolini (the only item I wasn't so fond of) and the complimentary bread (so good). I will be back!
Be the first to ReplyReally great service and the octopus app was very flavorful.
The popovers were amazing. The lobster tails were fresh but lacked flavor.
Be the first to ReplyThis is the perfect restaurant for a date night.
The lighting was mellow but not too dark, the staff was incredibly nice and pleasant, and the food was amazing. Highly recommend the drinks Hazed & Confused and Bubbs on Top, and the octopus as an appetizer!
Be the first to ReplyMade a reservation for my birthday for myself & a few of my
Made a reservation for my birthday for myself & a few of my family. My dad gave me a gift at dinner, which I accidentally left under my seat. We were the last table to leave that night, so I immediately call the restaurant after we left & leave a voicemail letting them know & that I'll be back the next day. No one calls back at all. I call twice more the next day and nothing. I went back when the they opened & they tell me no one saw my gift bag. Asked for a mgr, we got Duncan Glaser, Director of Operations who spoke with my mother and I & he showed absolutely no care towards my situation. He insinuated we were lying by saying maybe I took it home. We suggested he check the cameras to prove I didn't leave with it & he said no. Basically an employee found my bag & kept it. Ruined my birthday. For the amount of money to be spent on food here I would never expect to be treated like that.
Be the first to ReplyHands down one the sexiest modern comfort steakhouse in
Hands down one the sexiest modern comfort steakhouse in Time Square. Great mood lighting, vibe, and music!!Must try:Freshly baked house bread with whipped herb butterPacific oystersCrab cake10oz filet w/ pepper brandy sauceCream of spinachMashed potatoes Paired with Makers old fashioned for the hubby Captain Morgan and Coke for meTopped it off with Chocolate Pecan Bourbon layered cake!
Be the first to ReplyAbsolutely fabulous dinner experience.
Food was superb - juicy, well seasoned steaks, fresh seafood delivered that day, pasta made in house. Attentive and very helpful service (thank you Jorgรฉ/George!). Large wine list with the not unexpected elevated price point mark-ups. Another perk - a heavy, serrated steak knife with a curved handle that does all the work as gravity takes over and glides through my glistening, medium rare steak with ease. Are you salivating yet? No need to be Pavlovian any longer - eat here and leave happy!
Be the first to ReplyThe staff was responsive from the moment we stepped into
The staff was responsive from the moment we stepped into the restaurant and they checked our vaccine cards. They were kind and recommended great pairings for drinks and dessert. The sword fish was seasoned well but some of the veggies soaked up the sauce which made them taste very acidic. Overall I enjoyed the ambiance of the restaurant and the meal.
Be the first to ReplyVery disappointed at the way this place handled there
Very disappointed at the way this place handled there recent building issue. They were closed for days but I did not receive any alerts. I just happened to see on instagram the night before that they were closed. They did NOT notify RSVP ppl of this issue. I had to call multiple times to get an update. It's ok if you are waiting for conEd & don't know exactly what is going on but I had organized this celebration dinner with a group of friends weeks in advance & had you notified us sooner we could have better planned a back up place in case instead of scramming a few hours before our dinner & people coming in from out of state. Unprofessional!
Be the first to ReplyA friend of mine posted on IG that food in NY isn't good
A friend of mine posted on IG that food in NY isn't good and I was reminded that about that time I stumbled in Hunt & Fish. I really enjoyed my visit to NY & I'm telling everyone who I can that this place was amazing! I ordered the Lemon Chicken & although that's prob the most basic thing on the menu I was impressed. 10/10
Be the first to ReplyI honestly feel embarrassed for dining here.
An extremely expensive place with terrible martinis and mediocre food. You are uncomfortably packed in this place and it is extremely loud for some reason. The whole place smells like a bathroom before you even go downstairs to the actual bathroom. The rumor is that many celebrities frequent this place and I'm completely unsure what the draw would be. If you want an expensive dinner, with a view, with delicious food, and $25+ martinis that are actually good.. there are so many other places to go. I'm posting this because it is a complete waste of $.
Be the first to Reply