San Matteo New York Tripadvisor Reviews - San Matteo New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at San Matteo New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at San Matteo New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of San Matteo New York
San Matteo New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
13 Reviews
0 Replys |
Best pizza
Go here!! You will not be disappointed. The pizza is delicious, including the most spectacular crust. Great staff and service!
Be the first to ReplyBest pizza in the UES
Tiny hole in the wall that has the best pizza Iโve had in Manhattan. The atmosphere is amazing, like family. And the owner is so welcoming. Just delicious wood fired thin crust pizza and amazing polpetta that I dream about. Burratta is fantastic too
Be the first to ReplyAverage NYC pizza.
The pizza was a good quality. We tried three different types. However it is not Grmaldiโs nor Lucaliโs of the pizza super competitive NYC world. The antipasto was out of the can and not freshly prepped. The waiter had a wrong attitude around when we asked to replace the cups since we felt the cups were not clean. If you are really hungry, then go, but if you have a choice go to a higher quality pizza shop. You may find plenty of them in NYC.
Be the first to ReplyExceptional Eatery
My family and I had dinner at San Matteo Pizzeria in NYC. We went there once before for dinner and we were overwhelmed by the delectable food, amazing wine selection and outstanding staff and owner. The food is truly melt in your mouth delicious. The wait staff are personable and eager to accommodate . The owner is outgoing, warm and affable. This restaurant is a must for those who value stellar food and service. We love this establishment and are anticipating a return visit.
Be the first to ReplyI had a family reunion here with my cousins from abroad.
I met some cousins at this restaurant for dinner on a Sunday night. There was both indoor and outdoor (with a roof) dining. The restaurantโs interior was clean but it was also small. There was a wait to eat indoors. I liked the pizza and the vegetarian panini entrees and I was pleased with the service of the staff. The food prices and the portions were satisfactory to me. I would come back again.
Be the first to Replybetter than in Italy
seriously the best pizza ever !!! Italian experience in New York. can recommend. I have already eaten pizza in Italy and it was not as good as this one.
Be the first to ReplyMr
Vaccine Passport needed to eat outside.
You have got to be joking!! They do NOT deserve anybody's custom
Delicious Pizza
As a tourist we envisioned going to an authentic Italian restaurant for a great oven-baked pizza. Weโll this is just that. You could hear everyone in the background yelling Italian and the food is superb. Perhaps not a good first date place, but if youโre looking for good authentic Italian food โ this is it.
Be the first to ReplyDelightful Pizza Experience in New York City
San Matteo is quite an experience when it comes to pizza. I use to pass by their shop on 2nd Avenue, always observing long lines and would wonder what the hype was about. I decided to give it a try and ordered a Margherita, and a Hawaiian Pizza. No disappointment here. All fresh abundant flavors, a magical tad sweet tomato sauce with a nice thin crispy crust. How much can you possibly say about pizza? All I can do is recommend San Matteo and tell you if you're on the Upper East Side, give it a try. You won't be disappointed.
Be the first to ReplyOutstanding pizza
My partner and I had many mediocre pizzas in New York and we were so happy when we finally went to San Matteo. Their pizza is amazing, perfectly done and with the freshest ingredients coming straight from Italy - and it is the genuine Neapolitan pizza, no doubt. Their starters and desserts are lovely too (we love their burrata and the delizia al limone in particular), and their Aperol Spritz are spot on. We have been going as often as we can for the past 2 years - and even during the Covid19-pandemic we have enjoyed their pizza to take out and more recently we have been enjoying the outdoor dining space. Staff are nice and professional, service is fast. We will certainly go back!
Be the first to ReplyAmazing pizza!
High quality authentic pizza, top-notch! Service was great too.
I had a prosciutto and was to die for..the crust is superbe.
Thanks for the great evening!
Mark
For when you get tired of American style pizza!
I love San Matteo. We've eaten there maybe 4 times now and taken friends. The thin crust Italian based pizza reminds us of Franco Manca (for the Brits reading this). Delicious and slightly charcoalled in places.
The ravioli with vodka sauce is a must try, and their arugula salad - which is like a small mountain, which comes with pine nuts and goats cheese is delicious.
Don't bother with the tiramisu, which was not a traditional slab but made in a small glass and the layers hadn't had time to meld together into the heavenly dessert we know.
The restaurant is a little cold, and the service is sometimes good, sometimes OK, but go for the food!
Excellent pizza
Four of us went here for lunch on a Saturday afternoon. We were seated right away and our orders were taken quickly. We ordered 2 pizzas and a spinach salad. The food and service was very good. The prices seemed a little high, but we enjoyed it.
Be the first to Reply