Scalini Fedeli New York Tripadvisor Reviews - Scalini Fedeli New York - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at Scalini Fedeli New York for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at Scalini Fedeli New York from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
New York's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Scalini Fedeli New York
Scalini Fedeli New York Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
11 Reviews
0 Replys |
Truly Exceptional
Amazing Italian food and superb service. Tonight was a price fix menu which is fine. they first brought three two-bite very flavorful appetizers: salmon crostini, shrimp in mustard sauce, zucchini in a tomato sauce all of which were incredibly tasty. The ravioli appetizer was, hands down, the best ravioli I've ever had, and the salmon in mushroom sauce was world class. Really enjoyed Scalini Fedini and will most definitely return on my next trip to New York
Be the first to ReplyAmazing Night Out
Absolutely amazing dinner! We chose this place based on the TripAdvisor reviews and we were so glad we did! The restaurant has an old world feel. The service was impeccable, the wine was delicious, but the food…! It was amazing! Everything we ate was delicious. You will not leave hungry or disappointed.
Be the first to ReplyAmazing Italian chef Michael Cetrulo!
I cant find words to describe how amazing this Restaurant is. I went with my family. The food was delicious, inventive and superb. The chef is soo talented. The staff was professional and welcoming! The wine list is great! HIGHLY recommend it!
Be the first to ReplyHow wonderful some great things don't change!
Last time I ate here thirty years ago I was impressed. And 30 years later even more so. Gorgeous setting, incredibly what I thought had disappeared old-style service still exists. Very good food, lots of it, very different, awesome selection of wines, totally professional maitre'd of the type that are fading away. Can't wait to go again.
Be the first to ReplyGood and authentic Italian restaurant - try the veal chop
Stepping into the restaurant, I felt like I was transported to old Italy - groin vaulted ceilings, opera music in the background, Italian-speaking (and singing) staff. USD79 for a 3-course prix fixe menu was pretty good value for money, considering the standard of food, size of servings and the inclusion of amuse bouche and palate clesnser. I would describe everything that was served as "good old Italian fare". For example, if you ordered the pappardelle bolognese (primi), you would get fresh and unadulterated pasta that represent traditional excellence. The highlight for me though, must have been the veal chop (piatti principale), which was most flavourful.
A Special Place
This is not the first time I've been to this restaurant but it is always special. I am still a little anxious going into indoor restaurants due to COVID and the Maitre-D was especially accommodating and put us at a table where we were not too close to others. And he checked on us to make sure we were comfortable and enjoying our evening!
The restaurant is very elegant, the service is great as is the food. I have had truffle appetizers repeatedly when I've dined here and they never disappoint.
We will definitely return soon.
Wonderful meal
First, the restaurant is beautiful with all of the candles. Dinner was amazing with so many interesting choices for both the first and second courses. My wife had the Agnolotti (so good) following by the pork chop with arugula and beet salad on top (also very good). I eat out often and have never seen pasta with octopus and anchovy sauce. I asked the waiter if it was strong and he assured me it wasn't. Good call, one of the best and most unique pasta dishes I've had. It was followed with the veal chop which is incredible.
The meal was followed by sorbet and dessert. Both included. In summary the restaurant is fine dining at its best, but the price wasn't that bad and for the amount and quality of the food, a great value. We'll definitely be back.
Even better than we remember
We have not been to Scalini in a few years for obvious reasons and we are so glad to see the restaurant is up and running and doing well ,all the food that we had was fantastic and was difficult to finish ,all portions are very generous , service is also polished and friendly. We do dine out frequently and noticed that many of the better restaurants are having a hard time getting staff so we do understand that’s some restaurants are having trouble keeping their consistency but we are quite surprised here at Scalini it was even better than we remembered years ago!!
Be the first to ReplyCruise ship Italian food
I had high expectations based on the reviews, but was disappointed. While the service was excellent, the food was mediocre at best. We arrived towards the end of the evening and it was clear some of our first bites had been sitting for some time. The guancale in my amitriciana was tough. My duck was fine, but not very inspiring.
Overall, the food quality was on par w a cruise ship or an all inclusive resort - nothing horrible, but not the sort of Italian we were hoping for.
Price fix
What a hidden gem. I have never been here before and lived and worked in NYC for a long time. Dinner with some friends. Price fix type meal that was fabulous. Reasonably priced and lots of different choices brought to the table. Will return soon.
Be the first to ReplyStunning old-school Italian
One of the finest restaurants I've had the pleasure of visiting. The food is absolutely superb, the setting beautiful and service fantastic. They type of restaurant that makes you wish you could give 6 stars.
At $80, the fixed price menu is quite literally unbelievable value. They bill it as a 3 course menu, but in reality it's closer to 7 courses. Start off with excellent breads, followed by a selection of small plates, then starters (which are enormous), followed my main courses (also enormous) and then a dessert (but not before the pre-dessert palate cleaner.
Every course, without exception, was excellent. Unfortunately this style of restaurant seems to be going out of fashion, which is a shame, as this is the type of place you'll be treated wonderfully all night in a spacious and calm ambience. The presentation and setting is old-fashioned, as opposed to outdated.
Would come again without doubt. Come very, very hungry. And get the veal chop.