St. Elmo Steak House Beech Grove Tripadvisor Reviews - St. Elmo Steak House Beech Grove - Buy Reservations
Getting a Reservation at St. Elmo Steak House Beech Grove for Today or Tomorrow is Easy!
Buy a verified reservation at St. Elmo Steak House Beech Grove from someone who doesn't need theirs anymore.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Indianapolis's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of St. Elmo Steak House Beech Grove
Ranked #20 in Indianapolis's Best Restaurants.
St. Elmo Steak House Beech Grove Tripadvisor Reviews
Latest Reviews On Tripadvisor
25 Reviews
0 Replys |
Best Shrimp Cocktail in the World
Best Shrimp Cocktail in the World. Unbeatable. Service was just as amazing! Would highly recommend that all visitors to Indianapolis pay them a visit.
Be the first to ReplySt Elmo was great as usual!
It was excellent and Duck or Ducky I canโt remember for sure was excellent. The temperature of our food was perfect also.
Be the first to ReplyDecent Meal
Three of us dined here on a Sunday night while in town on business. This was recommended due to history of restaurant. We had reservations ahead of time and were seated promptly. There arent any appetizers options beyond their โfamousโ shrimp cocktail. Of course we tried it and the cocktail sauce certainly clears any sinus issues. All of us went with their dry aged steak options and the sides are aโla carte. You can choose the lobster bisque for an up charge and it was good. The steak was good but certainly wasnโt in my top 5 steaks Iโve ever had, maybe not even top 10. My friends agreed with their steaks. We tried their blueberry bread pudding for dessert which was ok. Service was good and the drinks were decent. $650 for three was a steep price for an average meal. Would go elsewhere.
Be the first to ReplyGreat Shrimp Cocktail.. but there were issues.
The shrimp cocktail was the best I've ever had. The cocktail sauce.... you have to have it to understand. The steak was average for a top end steakhouse. Wasn't bad, wasn't great. I had the aged Strip. Others in my party had the filet, the regular strip and a ribeye. There were six of us total. The atmosphere was great. Service was great until....the bill came. First time the bill was brought out, there was a charge for a $49 pour of bourbon I didn't order and didn't receive. I pointed it out, the waiter apologized. The second time it was brought out there were 7 steaks on our bill, when we only had 6. Again, I pointed it out. And it was corrected. There are two possibilities... either it was intentional or it was a mistake on our servers part. Either way it's not good, $140 worth of overcharge. It was corrected and the server wouldn't make eye contact with me when he collected payment. One shouldn't have to dissect the bill to ensure they are not being overcharged. Not what you expect at this type of restaurant, or really any restaurant.
Be the first to ReplyFantastic Steak House
This is one of the best steak houses in the country, and certainly the best restaurant in Indianapolis. The food is great, the drinks are strong, service is superb and the setting is very nice. Go with the 8 ounce filet, onion rings for the table, and chocolate mousse pie as a shared dessert.
Be the first to ReplyExceptional!!
St.Elmo far exceeded all expectations I had. Both the food and service were exceptional, and this is a place that I will always come back to. If you are anywhere near Indianapolis you need to make sure you stop her.
Be the first to ReplyA must when you visit Indy! Plan ahead, make reservations!! My husband said it was the best steak ever! Shrimp a must!
Wanted to chose a special place for my 70th birthday!! Didn't dissapoint! Joel was a great waiter and all the staff are top notch!!
Be the first to ReplyGreat place in Indy
Great food!! Everything came out just as we ordered. Wait staff were friendly and knew there menu, was disappointed that noone circled back around after food was almost gone to ask us how we were on drinks!! Other then that, we all had a great night and very good food!
Be the first to ReplyGreat food, and superb service! We had dinner with our volleyball team, and enjoyed the private room dining. The loung
Great food, and superb service! We had dinner with our volleyball team, and enjoyed the private room dining. The lounge is awesome and great for any celebration. Best steak and shrimp in town.
Be the first to ReplyGreat food
Must have shrimp cocktail!!! Be ready!!!! The steaks were phenomenal. Cooked perfect. Service was top notch. Definitely coming back again
Be the first to ReplyExcellent steak!
Great experience, server was Mark. Shrimp Cocktail had a kick as expected, filet was tender. Would return the next trip to Indy!
Be the first to ReplyUse to be great.
Such a disappointment - the first filet was so overly seasoned it was inedible - then the next two were cooked well done - so sad! They did take the filet off the bill BUT so disappointing.
Be the first to ReplyA must go for dinner
St. Elmo is an Indy staple. A must go for dinner. The food is amazing. The staff & management are even better than that. Enjoyed the food, the atmosphere & the people.
Be the first to ReplyHad better food at El Rodeo in Speedway
I had shell pieces in my mouth from the oysters Rockefeller and had to spit it out. Was not offered a comp. Crab and shrimp was rubbery and crab mac and cheese was very bland. Shrimp cocktail,, Asparagus, mashed potatoes and creme brulee was good.
Be the first to ReplyBirthday celebration
The food is amazing! Phillip has an amazing personality. The ambience is so great. My favorite restaurant in the city! Phillip or Glenn are the best in the business at waiting on your table.
Be the first to ReplyDelicious but pricey
The food was great from appetizer to dessert! The shrimp cocktail was different and tasty. The porterhouse, potatoes, and mac n cheese did not disappoint. The cheesecake was good as well. The wine and cocktail selection was very good; however, prices and "enhancements" seemed a bit pricey.
Be the first to ReplyQuality all round
Came here as a party of 5, service was excellent, food was very good and the place has a real buzz about it, would certainly recommend for a special occasion
Be the first to ReplyExcellent downtown steakhouse
Other than the difficulty of getting a reservation, which speaks to how excellent they are, this was a delightful experience. Our steaks were cooked to perfection, salad and soup tasty, wine very good. Service was outstanding, our waiter was excellent but what put it over the top was the number of staff members walking by to clear empty plates and refresh beverages. But, before moving anything, they asked if it was OK. They asked! It was wonderful. The check was high, but that is not a surprise for the quality of atmosphere, service, and food.
Be the first to ReplyTourist Trap
We were visiting from out of town and excited to try St. Elmoโs by reputation. Itโs completely over rated! We knew it is pricey but why order a $75.00 steak and pay an extra $5.00 for bearnaise sauce, really? We waited one hour between the soup and the main course. The young hostess was snarkyโฆatmosphere was like Grand Central Station. The food was good but the ambiance is completely lacking.
Be the first to ReplyAlways a place to celebrate
We have been to St. Elmo's around ten times. It is a special celebration that usually makes us go there. We pick it every time. We were again in LOVE with the great food and service. I got the lamb and my husband got the ribeye. I thought the lamb with the chateaubriand sauce and mashed potatoes were so good. I can't wait to have that again. My husband's ribeye was perfect. We always get the shrimp cocktail, yum! The navy bean soup is excellent. We end with creme brulee. Thank you for making our night special!
Be the first to ReplyAlways Great
Itโs not a trip to Indy without a trip to St Elmoโs so this time we went twice! The first nite we at in the restaurant and had great dinners, drinks and service. Iโm not sure of our servers name but i believe it was Rick he had a pony tail and gave us excellent service. The next nite we went to the lounge especially to see Tasha because she was amazing when we went there before and she was so great again. We really appreciate Tasha and will be back to see her again. Once again the food was great and the shrimp cocktail is always the star of the show! Would love it if you would add the bacon appetizer to the dining room menu. Great experience!
Be the first to ReplyWhat is not to like about St.Elmo?
I went here tonight with a very pretty friend and she even helped me with the shrimp cocktail, Which at this place is a very unique experience, I had the filet mignon and a baked potato and it was amazing as always, I think she had halibit, I took a bite as well it was great. I had an old fashioned to drink and it was really good too, They really treat you great here. It is expensive but you know that going in. The inside of the place is kind of makes you feel like you are in the 1920"s. It is fancy as they say enjoy!
Be the first to ReplyCan't wait to return!
My husband and I went here for a dinner for the first time and loved every minute of this fine dining experience! We had amazing craft cocktails, shrimp cocktail (with the infamous sauce!), wagyu sliders, chopped BLT salad, filet mignon and stuffed shrimp. Everything was off-the-charts good and loved the warm and dark atmosphere especially on a cold evening. The assortment of breads offered were also melt-in-your mouth good! Matt was our server and couldn't have provided better service - he was very attentive and personable and we would ask for him again when we return. We are from Cincinnati and have several steak houses to choose from but felt St. Elmo's blows them away in terms of both service and quality of food. We loved our evening here and can't wait to return!!
Be the first to ReplyWonderful experience !
Sara set the bar high for all future waitresses. We learned a little about the restaurant and loved our visit
Be the first to ReplyTrip
Lived the atmosphere, staff and steaks. The shrimp were great but a bit spicy for wife. We would go back and order the aged versions.
Be the first to Reply