The Witchery by the Castle Edinburgh Yelp Reviews - The Witchery by the Castle Edinburgh - Trade Reservations
Save up to 30% at The Witchery by the Castle Edinburgh!
Have someone use their loyalty points to book your stay or buy a reservation from someone who can't make it to theirs.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservations!
All listed Reservations are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Edinburgh's Best Hotels that are most frequently booked by customers of The Witchery by the Castle Edinburgh
The Witchery by the Castle Edinburgh Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
12 Reviews
0 Replys |
The ambience was great! The staff was very attentive and
The ambience was great! The staff was very attentive and the food was really good. We enjoyed the evening. We would definitely recommend.
Be the first to ReplyThis spot had such a unique vibe.
All the staff members were very friendly. The service was phenomenal. I had the buckie brown crab as the appetizer then the grilled lemon sole as my main dish. I enjoyed the, but it would have been nice to be paired with some sort of side. The fish was honestly the best fish I've ever had. However, this also should have come with sides. At least over mashed potatoes or broccolini. I'm giving it four stars because the portion sizes are small, and the prices are extremely high. The toilet was clogged in the bathroom, and I found a piece of hair on my fish. This is not acceptable for a meal that is almost $100.
Be the first to ReplyWhat a lovely restaurant.
I had lunch. I selected the "lite lunch" and it was more than enough food. Highly recommend the "Fish Pie" menu. In addition, the Paris Brest dessert was over the top! Absolutely recommend!
Be the first to ReplyI booked for lunch a few weeks before we visited Edinburgh
I booked for lunch a few weeks before we visited Edinburgh and we had their set lunch menu. They advertise it as a light lunch, but we were so full afterwards we didn't have room for pudding. The service was top notch and very happy we came here. I chose the dining room instead of their garden area. If we ever come back again I would go to the garden area to eat. Both were lovely, but very different.
Be the first to ReplyAmbience: on point.
Everything was beautiful from the exterior into the interior. Romantic, classy, intimate, just lovely. Service: exceptional, I'm a big supporter of empty dishes being removed promptly and drinks refilled. Our serving staff was also on point the entire time. Food: we ordered the meal for two, COTE DE BOEUF With Roscoff onion, celeriac gratin and Bordelaise sauce. The beef was amazing, cooked to our personal liking. The potatoes were ok, there was some type of flavor that wasn't my favorite, but this is just my personal taste. For dessert we had the Chocolate tarte, and it had every flavor it described. Did not disappoint. We both had a glass of wine with dinner and dessert cocktails. I would like to give a 4.5, only part I thought was lacking was the main meal for the price should have included a vegetable or something else and the potato wasn't my favorite. Overall, we were still pleased. *** The menu is also seasonal, go to their website to view the current menu. ***
Be the first to ReplyThis was a lovely meal in such a gorgeous atmosphere with
This was a lovely meal in such a gorgeous atmosphere with top notch service. I couldn't be more pleased with our choice to dine here while in Edinburgh. Highly recommend!
Be the first to ReplyWhile the food was good the service was terrible.
Our server was lovely but the manager (who takes payment only I am assuming) was so unbelievably rude I was shocked. I asked for the wifi password while he was setting a table (restaurant was pretty empty) but I first interrupted and said "excuse me" he responded "what." not in a nice tone either. I was taken back but got over it. Then he brought out the bill, which I was splitting, and he went to mansplain the optional donation which I never asked to donate to. I am not from the UK and felt bullied and looked down on for not wanting to donate. While the atmosphere was nice and very photogenic the manager was not. Go somewhere else.
Be the first to ReplyThe Witchery is all about the magnificent period rooms,
The Witchery is all about the magnificent period rooms, location to Edinburgh Castle, the tremendous restaurants, and a charming staff. So if great history, food and people are your thing, welcome! Our Library room (pictured) was exquisite. It felt like stepping back 250 years in time. Hidden doors, dark nights, spiral staircase, and creaking floors. It's like living in Ebenezer Scrooge's house! The food was fantastic all during our stay (see separate review). We would pop out of our room and there we were at The Castle or St Giles. Just amazing. Can't say enough. And it always comes down to the people who were just so great to us all. Tremendous good time.
Be the first to ReplyWe didn't have a reservation, and I'm told that this place
We didn't have a reservation, and I'm told that this place is incredibly difficult to get into without one. However, we were very sweet to the hostess and told her we simply wanted to stop in for a glass of wine and so she accommodated us, and let us sit on the patio for a glass of bliss. What a cool place! Definitely one to come back to if ever in Scotland again. It looked like a high roller's spot for sure. You can tell that it would be worth the price tag. Someone let me know!
Be the first to ReplyTHE BEST restaurant we've been to as avid world travelers!
THE BEST restaurant we've been to as avid world travelers! An enchanting atmosphere like no other! You enter through a whimsical garden alley right up to the entrance. The food was impeccable with incredibly delicate details. Our best memory from our shared time in the UK. Edinburgh is magic around every corner. We brought our baby with us who was sleeping and did not disturb others but reading other reviews it looks they don't allow children anymore.
Be the first to ReplyThe Witchery is beautiful and elegant.
The light is low and perfect for a dinner for two. Or if you are traveling solo, it's a lovely place to dine alone to admire the decorations and ambience. I ate in the secret garden dining room (see pictures), but you can't go wrong with either dining room. The Witchery is definitely expensive, but I cannot say the cost wasn't worth it. For the experience and delicious foods, this restaurant was a delightful visit. Not to mention, the service is prompt, attentive, and kind. Also--the Valrhona Bitter Chocolate Torte is a must if you stay for pudding.
Be the first to ReplyA great five star experience! Found this gem on Instagram
A great five star experience! Found this gem on Instagram and figured we'd give it a shot. Can be a bit pricey but for white table linen service- you pay for what you get. Food was well designed and we enjoyed the scallops! It's a must!
Be the first to Reply